These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (2024)

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (1)

It's not over until you've had a slice (or three) of pie.

By Christopher Michel and Beth Branch

There's so much to enjoy about Thanksgiving, from visiting with family to enjoying the season.

Then there's the Thanksgiving menu: the turkey and your favorite side dishes, like mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce. But we know what everyone is actually thinking about come dinner time. It's all those pies cooling in the kitchen!

There are many other delicious Thanksgiving dessert options available, like Thanksgiving cakes and Thanksgiving cookies. But when it comes to capping off the annual feast, nothing quite compares to a gorgeous array of Thanksgiving pies.

1

Easy-Peasy Pie Dough

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (3)

The perfect pie often starts with a good homemade pie dough. This recipe is practically foolproof.

Get the recipe for Easy-Peasy Pie Dough.

2

Apple Butter Pie with Quilt Top Crust

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (4)

Inspired by the great state of Pennsylvania, this apple butter pie is a sweet alternative to both apple and pumpkin pies. The striking “Ribbon Star” quilt block top crust makes it a Thanksgiving sideboard showstopper.

Get the recipe for Apple-Butter Pie.

3

Bruléed Pumpkin Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (5)

It's just not Thanksgiving without a pumpkin pie on the sideboard. We took the best-tasting classic recipe and added one incredibly smart upgrade: a thin, crunchy crust of burnt sugar on top that makes the whole pie absolutely sing.

Get the recipe for Bruléed Pumpkin Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

4

Salted Maple Syrup Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (6)

This creamy pie is an absolute-must for maple fans! With a custard-like filling and flourish of flaky sea salt, it’s a supreme salute to sweet and savory.

Get the recipe for Salted Maple Syrup Pie.

5

Pecan-Brownie Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (7)

Brownie fans take note: There is a place for you at the pie table too! Combine brownies and pecan pie and watch the slices disappear!

Get the recipe for Pecan-Brownie Pie.

6

Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Fudge Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (8)

There's a lot of good stuff going on in this pie. The salted caramel and peanut butter topping on this pie makes this a chocolate dessert no one will forget!

Get the recipe for Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Fudge Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

7

German Chocolate Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (9)

Although Deutschland gets all the credit, German chocolate cake was named after American Sam German, who created the baking bar—“German’s Sweet Chocolate”—used in the batter. This pie version—deconstructed with a chocolate crust—takes the cake.

Get the recipe for German Chocolate Pie.

8

Brown Butter Apple Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (10)

Another classic fall flavor, apple pie gets a boost from brown butter. Be ready to field request for the recipe!

Get the recipe for Brown Butter Apple Pie.

9

Mocha Chocolate Cream Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (11)

After dinner coffee just got a lot sweeter. Chocoholics who are always looking for something fudgy on the dessert table after Thanksgiving dinner will adore this pie!

Get the recipe for Mocha Chocolate Cream Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

10

Peanut-Salted Caramel Slab Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (12)

If this year's Thanksgiving guest list is big—and your family loves that beguiling combo of sweet and salty flavors—bake up this massive slab pie.

Get the recipe for Peanut-Salted Caramel Slab Pie.

11

Braided Cranberry-Orange Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (13)

Cranberry sauce always sits in that strange place between dinner and dessert. Here, we've dressed it in a cable-knit-sweater-style crust and placed it firmly on the dessert plate.

Get the recipe for Braided Cranberry-Orange Pie.

12

Ginger Pumpkin Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (14)

If you find that traditional pumpkin pies just don't have enough bite, then this peppery-sweet recipe is your solution. With three different kinds of ginger, plus a gingersnap crust, it's incredibly satisfying.

Get the recipe for Ginger Pumpkin Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

13

Salted Caramel-Apple Slab Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (15)

Feeding a crowd? This impressive-looking centerpiece dessert guarantees everyone gets a slice.

Get the recipe for Salted Caramel-Apple Slab Pie.

14

Pecan, Hazelnut, and Coconut Tart

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (16)

Get a little nutty this Thanksgiving with this gooey, rich tart.

Get the recipe for Pecan, Hazelnut, and Coconut Tart.

15

Nancy Fuller's Double-Crust Apple-Cheddar Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (17)

The apple and Cheddar combination of this crowd-pleasing pie is perfect for both guests who are sugar lovers and guests who prefer savory tastes.

Get the recipe for Double-Crust Apple-Cheddar Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

16

Nancy Fuller's Pecan Slab Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (18)

Bring the comforts of a classic pecan pie together with the ease of a slab pie, and you have a divine creation. Serve warm with homemade whipped cream.

Get the recipe for Pecan Slab Pie.

17

Gingery Sweet Potato Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (19)

Upgrade your grandma's sweet potato pie with a ginger-infused cream topping.

Get the recipe for Gingery Sweet Potato Pie.

18

Maple-Nut Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (20)

Dig into a chocolate-drizzled riff on classic pecan pie.

Get the recipe for Maple-Nut Pie.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

19

Rocky Road Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (21)

You'll scream for this ice cream-inspired pie filled with chocolate, peanuts, and marshmallows.

Get the recipe for Rocky Road Pie.

20

Pretzel-Chocolate-Pecan Slab Pie

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (22)

Expecting a crowd on Thanksgiving? This sweet-and-salty pie feeds 16 people!

Get the recipe for Pretzel-Chocolate-Pecan Slab Pie.

These Are the Thanksgiving Pie Recipes Everyone Actually Wants (2024)

FAQs

What is the most popular pie eaten on Thanksgiving? ›

While pumpkin pie reigns supreme in the majority of American households, sweet potato pie is still the quintessential Thanksgiving dessert in the South. According to one theory, it was Henry VIII's love of sweet potato desserts that kicked off the popularity of yams in a pie.

What is the most popular dessert at Thanksgiving? ›

In general, pie reigns supreme as a Thanksgiving dessert. While some families have their nice selections of pie servings, tradition says apple, pumpkin pie, and a southern pecan pie are the go-tos, typically made with a buttery pastry pie crust.

Do Americans prefer apple pie or pumpkin pie for Thanksgiving? ›

Thanksgiving pies are a traditional part of Americans' modern-day feast, with harvest flavors dominating the country's favorite pies. Pumpkin pie is Americans' top choice for a Thanksgiving pie — with pecan pie, apple pie, and sweet potato pie right behind it.

What is America's number one selling pie? ›

The clear winner for the United States as a whole was (not surprisingly) apple pie with more than 27% of sales going to the traditional flavor.

What kind of pie did the Pilgrims probably eat at the first Thanksgiving? ›

Pumpkin Pie

Both the Pilgrims and members of the Wampanoag tribe ate pumpkins and other squashes indigenous to New England—possibly even during the harvest festival—but the fledgling colony lacked the butter and wheat flour necessary for making pie crust.

What is the most famous pie in the world? ›

Apple Pie. What it is: Somehow both quintessentially English and American, this may be the most famous pie of all. In Britain it goes back to the 1300s, and the earliest recipe includes figs and raisins. Modern recipes tend to consist of apples, sugar, butter and cinnamon encased in shortcrust pastry.

What pie is Texas famous for? ›

Texas Declares “Pecan Pie” the Official State Pie

Whereas, though there are many ways to enjoy pecans, it is practically a given among Texans that they belong, first and foremost, in a pie.”

What is the best tasting pie? ›

Popular pie flavors can vary by region and personal taste, but some of the most commonly enjoyed pie flavors include:
  • Apple.
  • Pumpkin.
  • Pecan.
  • Cherry.
  • Blueberry.
  • Key Lime.
  • Lemon Meringue.
  • Peach.
Feb 8, 2023

What is Florida's favorite pie? ›

Key lime pie was invented in Key West, where Key limes are anything but scarce. Key limes are different from regular limes. Key limes are more aromatic, smaller, seedier and are more tart than regular limes. Key lime pie is the Sunshine State's official state pie.

What is the most popular pie in the Midwest? ›

The Midwest - Cherry Pie

Cherry pie holds a special place in the hearts of Midwesterners, who celebrate the region's abundant cherry harvest with this sweet and tart treat. Whether it's enjoyed with just the lattice crust or an added dollop of whipped cream, this pie is a Midwest favorite year-round.

What is the percentage of Americans who eat pie on Thanksgiving? ›

On Thanksgiving, pumpkin pie is a welcome sight for most Americans. In a 2022 survey, approximately 40 percent of respondents said that they would "Love it" to be served. Additionally, about 30 percent of respondents stated they like pumpkin pie to be served at a Thanksgiving meal.

What is the most commonly eaten food on Thanksgiving? ›

1. Turkey. Thanksgiving wouldn't be the same without the turkey. The turkey is usually prepared whole, filled with fruit, vegetables or other stuffing (more on stuffing in #2!).

Why is pumpkin pie so popular at Thanksgiving? ›

Northeastern Native American tribes grew squash and pumpkins. The Native Americans brought pumpkins as gifts to the first settlers, and taught them the many uses for pumpkin. This led to serving pumpkin pie at the first Thanksgiving in America about 50 years later.

What is the most traditional Thanksgiving meal? ›

The classic Thanksgiving dinner includes old-time favorites that never change: turkey, gravy, stuffing, potatoes, veggies, and pie. But the way these dishes are made or added to is everchanging because of food trends and different dietary requirements.

Do people eat apple pie on Thanksgiving? ›

Here's a look at the top nine pie types Americans are eating this Thanksgiving: Apple - 20% Strawberry - 19% Pumpkin - 16%

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5885

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.